History

Muttontown has a rich history dating back to colonial times:

• Originally inhabited by the Matinecock Native Americans
• European colonists began settling in the area during the 1600s
• The area was historically used to raise sheep for wool and meat
• Incorporated as a village in 1931
• The name “Muttontown” stems from its former use as pasturage for sheep

Demographics

As of 2024, Muttontown’s key demographic information includes:

• Population: 3,495 (growing at a rate of 0.09% annually)
• Median Age: 46.9 years (49.3 for males, 46.7 for females)
• Racial Composition:
  • White: Majority
  • Asian: Second largest group
  • Other races and Two or more races: Smaller percentages
• Foreign-born population: 30.92%

Economy and Housing

Muttontown is known for its affluence and high property values:

• Average Household Income: $359,201
• Poverty Rate: 3.66%
• Homeownership Rate: 95.4%
• Average Household Size: 3.09
• Average Family Size: 3.31

Education

Muttontown is served by multiple school districts:

• Jericho Union Free School District
• Locust Valley Central School District
• Oyster Bay–East Norwich Central School District
• Syosset Central School District

Educational attainment is high, with 77.91% of white residents holding a bachelor’s degree or higher.

Community and Lifestyle

Muttontown offers residents:

• Exclusive and private atmosphere
• Large estates and spacious properties
• Strong focus on preserving rural character
• Proximity to New York City (approximately 25 miles)
• Diverse community with a significant Asian population

Notable Residents

Muttontown has been home to several notable individuals, including:

• Alicia Keys, singer/songwriter
• Al Trautwig, sports commentator
• Cliff Josephy, Professional Poker Player
• Lester L. Wolff, former member of the United States House of Representatives
• Chad Pennington, football quarterback
• Jose Reyes, infielder for the New York Mets

Conclusion

Muttontown, NY, offers a unique combination of rural charm, historical significance, and modern affluence. Its commitment to preserving its character, coupled with its proximity to urban centers and prestigious institutions, makes it a highly desirable location for those seeking an exclusive lifestyle on Long Island.